Monday, April 18, 2016

The Search for Black Bottle blended Scotch

It's always nice to discover an affordable economy blended Scotch that punches way above its weight class.  Black Bottle was once a great blend delivering luscious Islay notes in a cheap bottle.  Here is my old review of that beauty: http://jason-scotchreviews.blogspot.ca/2011/05/review-black-bottle-blended-scotch.html

Unfortunately, in 2013, the flavor profile changed dramatically (as the corporate masters sought to increase sales by going for the lowest common denominator) from a strong Islay influence to a boring, mainstream Speyside style.  Nevertheless, one of my readers, Bob, and I were trading some email, as he searched for the best affordable blends. Here is his tale of Black Bottle discovery that he emailed me the other day:

It's rare that I am in the right place at the right time, like when Microsoft first offered it's stock to me circa 1985 and I poo-pooed it at the time when it was around $5 a share and had yet to split about a dozen times after that. Ahhh, a $5000 investment at the time would probably be worth $350,000+ today but to even think about it still makes me sad so I will digress. Thus, I will fast forward to the present to get to the gist of this e-mail rather than waxing poetic on love scorned, opportunities lost, ad infinitum.

So for the past 2 months since reading all the rave reviews about Black Bottle blended Scotch, only to read further that all the fuss was about the old bottling I had pretty much made up my mind that it was just not in the cards for me. I am not (read 'my wife will not let me') buy a bottle at auction for $120 or more. Or order one from the U.K. and have to endure a 55 £ shipping charge. So I resigned myself to finding a bottle of the 'new' version in person rather than ordering one. Which was no small feat! Pennsylvania and New Hampshire have state stores that all carry the same stuff and neither state stocked Black Bottle. Ditto Vermont. So I scoured Connecticut and found one place that had it in stock, but at $26.99 a bottle I passed figuring another store would have it for less (I had seen it for $20 online) on the same trip. Well after 200 miles of driving and 9 additional stops, I was kicking myself for not getting it, just to try it.


Several weeks and dozens of stores in various states later, I could still not find a store that stocked Black Bottle and most had never even heard of it. Then on a whim my wife and I were away on a short business trip (I sell used & rare bass guitars for a living after suffering as an accounting manager back in those early Microsoft stock days) and it was late so I decided to just try one more store before we headed to our hotel. I headed right for the Scotch aisle and of course, started at the bottom shelf. Right next to the Inver House I saw a 'sale' tag for Black Bottle at $17.99 but did not see any. I bent down and moved a few bottles around and there on the bottom shelf, behind the Inver House were. They were covered in dust with the original hang tags on them! I only saw one at first and acted as if I had discovered the Mother Lode, according to my wife. I was in shock as I got down on my stomach and pulled out a 2nd, 3rd and 4th bottle! Of course, later in the week when I had to drive through the area I tried every dinky liquor store within a 40-mile radius and as expected, not a single one had ever heard of Black Bottle new or old. 

So I consider myself as lucky as if I hit the lottery or something like that! The thrill of the hunt was as exciting as actually finding a few bottles of 'the good stuff' and I feel a bit let down now that it's over. Of course I won't stop looking but my short-term obsession has waned more out of necessity than anything else. Now I just have to sit down and try it when I am back home in a few weeks! We are in Denver, Colorado this week so I'll scour the area a bit for a small prize before I get worn out.


Best, Bob

8 comments:

  1. I recently bought a bottle in South Carolina, for less than $30 (maybe 26). It did not seem to be as good a I remembered it. Same experience with a recent purchase of JW Green. That one is definitely different and "hollow" compared to previous tastings. Great Blog!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Having been a devotee of Scotch whisky for 40 years, and have read many reviews, I believe you have the best reviews because they tell it like it is.My all time favorite blended Scotch is King's Ransom which was available in Canada until the lat 1980's when the eventual owner of Edradour distillery discontinued this wonderful product. Fortunately, I have an adequate supply to address moments when something special is warranted. Glad to have found you - I'm a recent subscriber. Scotty - Little Rock, AR

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Scotty for commenting. Sometimes I feel like I am posting an empty void on the internet and people think I am a little nuts.

      Cheers!

      Delete
    2. Hi, Scotty! I drive through Arkansas twice a year and it's nice to see it's no longer a 'dry' state. Many nice 'mom & pop' liquor stores certainly add to my driving time as I check them out. Chubby Cheeks in Texarkana has a great selection and some good sales! Last time through I got a gin distilled in Fort Smith and a big bottle of Little Rock's own Rock Town vodka. Maybe we can meet up at Brown's Buffet when I come by in mid-October! Bob

      Delete
  3. Good one Bob!! I would dearly love to come across those prices.... unfortunately my BB has grown on me so I'll soon be on the hunt again for that Pretty green bottle... Price is a kicker down here in Aus... I might get lucky...
    Al(from OZ)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bob here. This only proves I am the world's worst blogger! Here it is 5 weeks after Jason posted my ditty that I finally took notice. One final note was my wife's lone comment as I knelt down in front of the Mother Lode... "You're not going to buy them ALL, are you?" Wives have no concept of a Scotch no-brainer

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gee... that sounds exactly like what my better half would say Ha Ha !!!
    Still find it hard to part with $50 for a bottle.
    AL

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well.... I'm skunked! Local supplier where I previously got the old BB have re stocked with the new...out of luck guys.
    AL

    ReplyDelete